Judge rejects U.S. management plan for California desert (West Mojave)
By Ralph Maughan On September 30, 2009 · 7 Comments · In B.L.M., Motor Vehicles, Politics, Public Lands
Complicated ruling was a victory of sorts for conservation-
Judge rejects U.S. management plan for California desert. By Louis Sahagun. LA Times.
This was a huge case over a big area and a BLM plan that took 15 years to develop. My view of it as a partial victory is based on private email from kt. Perhaps kt will want to comment on it here.
Tagged with: Mojave desert

Ralph Maughan
Dr. Ralph Maughan is professor emeritus of political science at Idaho State University with specialties in natural resource politics, public opinion, interest groups, political parties, voting and elections. Aside from academic publications, he is author or co-author of three hiking/backpacking guides, and he is past President of the Western Watersheds Project.
7 Responses to Judge rejects U.S. management plan for California desert (West Mojave)
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Recent Posts
- Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home March 3, 2021
- Fire Suppression Hyperbole March 1, 2021
- Conservation Groups Swing Back at Bernhardt’s Last Minute Favor to Oregon Ranchers February 26, 2021
- South Plateau Timber Sale Another FS Con Job February 24, 2021
- Malheur Collaborative Bent On Degrading Forest Ecosystems February 22, 2021
Recent Comments
- Michael Kellett on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Ida Lupine on Reader generated wildlife news.
- Mark Gall on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- rastadoggie on Fire Suppression Hyperbole
- Craig Lacy on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Jyoti Josahentara on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Maggie Frazier on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Beeline on Reader generated wildlife news.
- Ida Lupine on Reader generated wildlife news.
- Ida Lupine on Reader generated wildlife news.
- Immer Treue on Reader generated wildlife news.
- Anita on Livestock industry’s campaign to get rid of wild horses is a scam to cheat the taxpayers
- snaildarter on Fire Suppression Hyperbole
- Ida Lupine on Reader generated wildlife news.
- Ida Lupine on Reader generated wildlife news.
This is a tough one. Having no plan (as opposed to a partially flawed one) allows the damage to continue. The ATV/dirt bike riders are a significant and organized political force in that area and will no doubt be the ones to seek the injuction of a new tighter plan and all the while the trails and the damage grow.
Mikepost, you are partially correct. I had the dubious distinction of being an ORV leader back in the early days of the California Desert Plan. It was the BLMs first major land use undertaking. I have completely seen the light and have been green for many years.
The OHV groups are well organised and all have “legal defense funds.” The funds are financed through entry fee surcharges and fundraisers. However, in todays legal market, I do not know how far these funds will go.
My suggestion to the Court, would be to order the BLM close the area until the BLM comes up with a Courrt approved plan. It has been done before on the old Barstow to Vegas course and it was very effective.
Rick
Anyone have more details on this or could point me somewhere? Does the decision extend across the entire California Desert District? I spent a year doing restoration on closed ohv routes near El Centro can vouch for more needing to be done.
Justin, As far as I know the West Mojave Plan covers the Ridgecrest and Barstow Field Office juresdictions. Perhaps part of the Needles office.
Go to http://www.blm.gov. Click on the California map then on one of the aforementioned field offices.You can then give them a call.
Rick
I am asking Western Watersheds Project’s California office to send me a copy of the decision.
OK, I have the decision text and have added it to the post.
Ralph, I am a little les than 1/3 of the way through the decision. It certainly is bringing back memories. I was directly involved in the 1982 CDCA Plan amendment. But those days are gone forever for me. Now I am one of “those tree-huggers.” What turned me around was the willful distruction of resouces by supposed OHV leaders in 1989. I have never regretted my decision to move away from the OHV communuty.
Rick