Much awaited hearing: Oil companys says plaintiffs in Highway 12 suit lack standing
Hearing officer limits testimony he will consider to small matters-
The much awaited hearing on giant oil machinery on Highway 12 was held today in Boise. It sounds like the Idaho Dept. of Transportation hearing officer will oil the way for the movement of the giant oil modules.
The hearing officer said he would only consider the first 4 modules, not the hundreds more to follow. The first 4 go to the Billings, Montana refinery, not Alberta’s tar sand pits.
The oil company said the plaintiffs, 4 citizens along Highway 12, lack standing to because they weren’t singled out — the transport won’t affect them to any greater extent than other citizens along the highway. Happily for Conoco, the hearing officer also said he would limit his review to whether foes have a right to get involved at this stage of the process.”
Oil company says foes lack standing in US 12 case. By Todd Dvorak. AP (from Business Week)
Boise Weekly has a story giving more of the color of the hearing. Overflow Hearing on Oversized Loads. By George Prentice.

Ralph Maughan
Dr. Ralph Maughan is professor emeritus of political science at Idaho State University. He has been a Western Watersheds Project Board Member off and on for many years, and also its President. For many years he produced Ralph Maughan's Wolf Report. He was a founder of the Greater Yellowstone Coalition. He and Jackie Johnson Maughan wrote three editions of "Hiking Idaho." He also wrote "Beyond the Tetons" and "Backpacking Wyoming's Teton and Washakie Wilderness." He created and is the administrator of The Wildlife News.
4 Responses to Much awaited hearing: Oil companys says plaintiffs in Highway 12 suit lack standing
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Recent Posts
- Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State August 15, 2022
- Western Rewilding Network Proposal August 9, 2022
- Holiday Farm Fire And Industrial Logging August 8, 2022
- Another Misleading New York Times Fire Article August 4, 2022
- San Pedro Grazing Challenged August 3, 2022
Recent Comments
- Beeline on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- lou on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Mark L on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Ida Lupine on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Ralph Maughan on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Jim Holyan on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Ida Lupine on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Ida Lupine on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Chris Zinda on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Chris Zinda on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Makuye on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Glenn Monahan on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Laurie on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- lou on Tribal Members Kill the Majority of Wolves in Washington State
- Beeline on Western Rewilding Network Proposal
Having lived on the Lochsa at Powell permanently and part-time, I find the unfolding of this story to be nothing short of completely depressing. I give a sincere tip of my hat to the couple who have challenged the big oil companies.
If ITD had involved the public sooner in the permitting process, ConocoPhillips may have delayed shipment and avoided storage and legal costs (they claim $2.5 million in damages from this delay) until they were sure permits were finalized. They took a chance based on ITD assurances all would go well. I’d laugh if Conoco turned around and sued the state for damages.
Where is the CBD when they might actually do some good…
MINING.com News – The Latest Mining News on the Web24, 2010 09:02 AM addthis_pub = ‘syscon’; TORONTO, ONTARIO — (Marketwire) — 11/24/10 — THIS PRESS RELEASE IS NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION TO ANY U.S. NEWS WIRE
http://news.mining.com/
hmmmm………