Building in disaster-prone areas should cost more
Pay to play: Building in disaster-prone areas should cost more. Salt Lake Tribune Editorial.
The editorial above is about Utah, but it uses California as the bad example (Utah is just as bad except that the population is smaller).
California’s current budget disaster is compounded by the costs of fighting the many fires — $13-million a day — with most of the high cost due to saving structures that never should have been built in wildlfire prone areas.
Why should others suffer monetarily because of obviously bad private decisions? In fact the bad decisions were made in part because the individuals and the developers understood that the costs of their decisions would not be borne by themselves alone.
Update (August 21) on the monetary effects of this on the Forest Service budget. Forest pinching pennies because of fire costs. By Corey Hatch. Jackson Hole News and Guide.
One effect we have seen is no monitoring of grazing and the livestock operators are running amuck.
Still more (August 22)- Defending Homes from Wildfire Costs Montana Millions. By Matthew Frank. New West.

Ralph Maughan
Dr. Ralph Maughan is professor emeritus of political science at Idaho State University with specialties in natural resource politics, public opinion, interest groups, political parties, voting and elections. Aside from academic publications, he is author or co-author of three hiking/backpacking guides, and he is past President of the Western Watersheds Project.
One Response to Building in disaster-prone areas should cost more
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Recent Posts
- Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home March 3, 2021
- Fire Suppression Hyperbole March 1, 2021
- Conservation Groups Swing Back at Bernhardt’s Last Minute Favor to Oregon Ranchers February 26, 2021
- South Plateau Timber Sale Another FS Con Job February 24, 2021
- Malheur Collaborative Bent On Degrading Forest Ecosystems February 22, 2021
Recent Comments
- Lyn McCormick on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Maggie Frazier on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Maggie Frazier on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Lyn McCormick on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Ida Lupine on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Lyn McCormick on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Ted MacKechnie on Critique of The West Is Burning Documentary
- Ida Lupine on Critique of The West Is Burning Documentary
- Ed Loosli on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- Ed Loosli on Critique of The West Is Burning Documentary
- Michael Kellett on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- jeff on Mexican wolf killings expose a dark underbelly of western culture
- Ida Lupine on Reader generated wildlife news.
- Mark Gall on Wilderness and Cows-Time to Send the Cows Home
- rastadoggie on Fire Suppression Hyperbole
The political advice I give to the Forest Service to make this problem go away real fast is to stop fighting forest fires. Say, “we’re plain out of money While we are obliged to deal with forest fires, we are obliged to do a lot of other things, and fires are no higher priority than many of the rest”
Congress would deal with the problem within a week or two and Bush wouldn’t dare veto it.