Thinned lodgepole pine forest on Oregon’s Deschutes National Forest. As often is the case, thinning puts more “fine” fuels on the ground which can promote fire spread. Photo George Wuerthner 

Montana Senator Daines announced that he intends to reintroduce wildfire legislation co-sponsored by California Senator Diane Feinstein that, among other things, would speed up and expand logging on public lands.  The presumption is that our forests are “sick” with too much “fuels” that are driving large blazes, and the “cure” is to reduce fuels through chainsaw medicine.

The continued emphasis on “fuels reduction” as the cure for large blazes reminds me of Medieval doctors who practiced bloodletting to cure illness. If a patient lived, it was because the “bad” blood had been removed. If the patient died despite bloodletting, then obviously not enough bad blood was drawn.

Bloodletting typically failed because it did not address the real medical issues causing illness. Similarly, thinning does not address the real cause of large fires.

Under most weather conditions, fires do not spread rapidly nor become large. Most fires burn less than 5 acres and typically self-extinguish or are easy to suppress.

Clearcuts and thinned forests did nothing to halt the wind-driven Jocko Lakes Fire in Montana. Photo George Wuerthner 

However, the fires that everyone is concerned about are the relatively few enormous blazes that burn tens of thousands of acres. These blazes all burn under “extreme fire weather conditions,” including drought, high temps, low humidity, and most importantly, high winds. Under extreme conditions, none of the logging “solutions” work.

Thinning/logging can exacerbate fire spread because it opens the forest to greater drying of the soils and ultimately vegetation and allows penetration by winds which drive all large blazes.

Thinning project Shasta Trinity NF CA. Removal of large trees does little to preclude fires that burn primarily in “fine fuels” consisting of pine needles, grass, shrubs, and small trees. Photo George Wuerthner 

Nearly all western forest and vegetation types, including lodgepole pine, subalpine fir, spruce, aspen, sagebrush juniper, and chaparral, tend to have “long” fire rotations.

Red fir in Mount Shasta Wilderness, CA. Most higher elevation forests in the West including lodgepole pine, fir, spruce, hemlock, and other species have long fire rotations (intervals between fires).  These forests do not dry out enough to carry a blaze in most years. However, under “extreme fire weather” including drought, such forests do burn readily. Photo George Wuerthner 

They go many decades, often hundreds of years, between burns. The chances that any fire in these plant community types will encounter a “fuel treatment” before trees or other vegetation grows back after thinning is very low—practically zero.

Needles, small branches, shrubs, grass, and small trees make up the bulk of all fuels that carry blazes. Chaparral in the San Bernardino Mountains of California. Photo George Wuerthner

It is fine fuels like needles, grass, and shrubs that burn in wildfires, not the larger trees. That is why we have snags after a blaze and why logging large trees will have little effect on fire spread during extreme fire weather.

Roads are a major impact to forest ecosystems. Sediments from road surfaces degrade aquatic ecosystems, road traffic disturbs wildlife, and weeds invade along Forest Service logging roads. Photo George Wuerthner

Logging is not benign. The logging roads created to cut trees are a significant source of sediment in streams impacting fisheries, vectors for weeds, disturb sensitive wildlife, are natural corridors for mountain bikes, dirt bikes, and other mechanical access even if “closed.” Plus, dead trees are habitat for many wildlife species.

Larger trees typically do not burn up in a blaze. They continue to store carbon in the snags, soil, and roots remaining after a high severity fire. Photo George Wuerthner

Logging also releases carbon that is otherwise stored in trees. Keep in mind that even after a fire, most carbon remains on-site stored as a snag, charcoal, roots in the soil, etc., so thinning reduces the stored carbon now, contributing to the climate warming that is exacerbating fires.

Home that is ready to burn in South Lake Tahoe, CA. The emphasis of federal fire policy should be on making homes fire-safe. Photo George Wuerthner 

Are we going to be like Medieval Doctors and just prescribe more chainsaw medicine? If the probability that a fire will encounter a fuel treatment is nearly zero, are they worth the costs?  A more effective cure is to focus on making homes fire-safe, not trying to “fire proof” the forest.

Tagged with:
 
avatar
About The Author

George Wuerthner

George Wuerthner is an ecologist and former hunting guide with a degree in wildlife biology

5 Responses to Daines and Feinstein Fire Legislation Misdirected

  1. avatar Bev Jo Von Dohre says:

    I so agree. I have been writing and talking to government agencies for years about the dangers of logging (“thinning”) in regards to wind and the other environmental devastation it causes. Thank you so much

  2. avatar Beeline says:

    Who will make us safe from our illustrious senators?

    • avatar Maggie Frazier says:

      So far – no one! This is yet another of Sen. Feinstein’s “issues”. Another is the continued ranching & livestock industry’s use of Point Reyes SEASHORE. That one was enough to turn me away from believing in her right there. Maybe time for retirement? And Sen. Daines has struck me as a typical (in this day & age) Repub.

  3. avatar Salle says:

    Any legislation with Daines’ name on it is a guarantee that it is bad legislation and his proposals should never find their way out of committee.

    Daines = Nothing good for We the People.

  4. avatar Dan Bushnell says:

    George,

    I’m glad that you post all the comments, both pro and con, on this website. It shows your true intent…

Leave a Reply to Beeline Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Calendar

May 2021
S M T W T F S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  

Quote

‎"At some point we must draw a line across the ground of our home and our being, drive a spear into the land and say to the bulldozers, earthmovers, government and corporations, “thus far and no further.” If we do not, we shall later feel, instead of pride, the regret of Thoreau, that good but overly-bookish man, who wrote, near the end of his life, “If I repent of anything it is likely to be my good behaviour."

~ Edward Abbey

%d bloggers like this: