Back to the drawing board on Hebgen Lake repair (Must read)
I notice a lot of people have been reading this story on the gate failures at Hebgen Dam, the news of which was first brought to us on Sept. 1 by “Idahosal.” (Salle)
They thought they had the way to fix the broken headgates at the dam, but it failed.
Oh Oh1 PPL back to the drawing board on Hebgen repair. AP
——-
Sept. 9
The news now is grim. The bulkhead plan did not work. There was too much turbulence at the dam intake for them to place the steel plate and stem the flow. At the moment there does not seem to be a “plan B”. The flow is still at springtime level. They are losing more than 5 inches of reservoir water elevation every 24 hours and this will accelerate as the level drops due to the cone shape nature of the reservoir bed. There are two scenarios that are scaring us at the moment.
Read the rest at http://www.mrfc.com/MadisonRiverMontanaFishing/MadisonRiverReport.aspx
Sept. 11. Remove boats before they are stranded, Hebgen Lake propert!y owners told. AP
Latest. Sept. 16. Progress slow in Hebgen Dam repair. By Andy Malby, editor. The Belgrade News

Ralph Maughan
Dr. Ralph Maughan is professor emeritus of political science at Idaho State University. He has been a Western Watersheds Project Board Member off and on for many years, and also its President. For many years he produced Ralph Maughan's Wolf Report. He was a founder of the Greater Yellowstone Coalition. He and Jackie Johnson Maughan wrote three editions of "Hiking Idaho." He also wrote "Beyond the Tetons" and "Backpacking Wyoming's Teton and Washakie Wilderness." He created and is the administrator of The Wildlife News.
4 Responses to Back to the drawing board on Hebgen Lake repair (Must read)
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Recent Posts
- Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court May 19, 2022
- BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review May 17, 2022
- Conservation Groups Threaten To Sue On East Paradise Grazing Decision May 12, 2022
- Gratitude for National Parks May 11, 2022
- Jimmy Carter Supports Protection of Izembek NWR Wilderness May 10, 2022
Recent Comments
- Jannett Heckert on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- rastadoggie on Gratitude for National Parks
- rastadoggie on Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court
- Megan on Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court
- Ida Lupine on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Ida Lupine on Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court
- Robert Raven on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Martha S. Bibb on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Maggie Frazier on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Ida Lupine on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Ida Lupine on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Laurie on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Charles Fox on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Maggie Frazier on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Ida Lupine on Gratitude for National Parks
hello all
I’ve been following this closely since it occured but have not read anything on the ecological implications of this. Will this have any negative effects? Are there any benefits that could come from this?
Thanks
Salle tells me she thinks the highway is being undermined at a spot about halfway along Quake Lake.
There are references in the article that imply the ecological harm may be wide-ranging. I can see where that could be true. We’re not just talking the Hebgen Lake reservoir, this is the Madison River and eventually, the Missouri. If the lake drains, there will be a lot to consider for the downriver regions.
We saw bears right where the roadbed seemed a little more ripply than when the runoff was heavy. There’s a steep slope and slides/rolling boulders occur often. the road is cut into the bank and set up on a corridor shelf arrangement that is above the water but the ground about ten to twenty feet below the corridor bed is likely to give way given the greater than normal current that flows through the lake with this release.
A constant flow of this magnitude at this level can eventually erode too much of the shelf and then the road will go.
Any engineers out there see what I mean? If any portion of the road gives, US287 will be closed. At this segment of road, from US191 to at least Ennis, cuts off traffic that is not allowed to travel through the park portion of US191, like hazardous materials trucks. Also, that high way is under much construction and has closures for a couple more weeks. This is a major corridor of truck and any other traffic out of the central Rockies.
If the lake goes, I too, wonder what will happen with some of the wildlife in the canyon and that depend on the lake in general.
Do we have an update on this situation anywhere? I did go to the dam website – the flow is still over 3100 cfs and the lake’s dropped over 6 feet.
Any word from PPL?