The annual, and always controversial count of elk on the Yellowstone northern range has been released. The northern range of Yellowstone extends well north of Yellowstone Park itself.
The news article concludes on the basis of speculation by a couple biologists that more elk are now living north of the Park due to the long term drought, lack of predators, and milder winters. A Montana state biologist says this makes the winter range north of the Park even more valuable. This is true. That range has always been invaluable and the state ought be buying more of it before it is completely filled with trophy homes.
If this is a trend, however, it takes more than one year to establish. One data point does not make a trend. This year’s elk count is two months late. As the winter progresses, these elk move to lower elevations, and that always means north. Until these “new” locations are replicated, we don’t know that elk are in general moving north.
It would certainly help if the agencies could get it together to count the elk at the same time every winter. That is what they are supposed to do — count at the same time each year. Otherwise, you end up with hard to compare figures.
Story. Count shows elk pushing north out of Yellowstone. By Mike Stark. Billings Gazette.
Ralph Maughan
Dr. Ralph Maughan is professor emeritus of political science at Idaho State University. He was a Western Watersheds Project Board Member off and on for many years, and was also its President for several years. For a long time he produced Ralph Maughan's Wolf Report. He was a founder of the Greater Yellowstone Coalition. He and Jackie Johnson Maughan wrote three editions of "Hiking Idaho." He also wrote "Beyond the Tetons" and "Backpacking Wyoming's Teton and Washakie Wilderness." He created and is the administrator of The Wildlife News.
Where’s Bob Wharf to eat his words when he guaranteed that coyotes weren’t getting any of the N. Range herd?Eleven percent of summer calf mortality was attributed to coyotes…that’s not the lion’s share–no pun intended–but it aint chump change,either. Anything to say about that Bob?
I guess elk are doing what they should be doing… adapting and moving around. Gee, I guess they deserve more credit than some people gave them. They really don’t just stand there petrified waiting to be eaten.
Coyotes are quite crafty, huh Bob?
Jay Says: “Where’s Bob Wharf to eat his words when he guaranteed that coyotes weren’t getting any of the N. Range herd?Eleven percent of summer calf mortality was attributed to coyotes…that’s not the lion’s share–no pun intended–but it aint chump change,either. Anything to say about that Bob?”
Jay, did Wharff say that on Ralph’s blog? Can you direct us to the specific page? Much appreciated…
—
Mack P. Bray
My opinions are my own
wildlifewatchers@bresnan.net
http://wildlifewatchers.jottit.com/
Yes, I can’t remember which post it was, though. In the thread of comments, I made a comment about the suite of predators taking elk, including coyotes, and BW’s response was a guarantee that coyotes weren’t getting any.
Gee, that’s funny…I thought the Northern Range Elk Herd was supposed to be extinct by now. At least, that’s what Bob Fanning “predicted” 4 years ago. In fact, he said they’d be extinct in *3* years.
What happened, Bob?