Tag: prescribed burning
-
National Prescribed Fire Act Flawed
Oregon Senator Ron Wyden is a co-sponsor of the National Prescribed Fire Act of 2025. The bill is ill-advised and based on flawed assumptions about the effectiveness and efficiency of prescribed burning. Prescribed burning is promoted as some magic bullet that can preclude large wildfires, but it has many disadvantages that are seldom discussed. The presumed…
-
More Timber Industry Propaganda from Oregon State University
Oregon State University (OSU) published a series of essays, “Not All Flames Are the Same,” on wildfire in Oregon. While the essays are written about Oregon forests, most of the main ideas about wildfire represented in the publications are similar to the propaganda found across the West. Like many forestry schools, the authors promote the…
-
South Cottonwood Proposed Wilderness Threatened
The South Cottonwood drainage in the northern Gallatin Range proposed wilderness lies immediately south of Bozeman, to the west of Hyalite Canyon. The Forest Service’s nearly 8,000-acre Hyalite Cottonwood Hazardous Fuels Reduction Project threatens some of the proposed wilderness. Keep in mind that one acre is approximately equal to a football field. So, imagine what…
-
Lessons from the LA Wildfires
The fires in Los Angeles are still burning as I write this. The loss of property, the disruption and loss of lives, and the trauma these fires created are horrendous. Nevertheless, there are lessons we can learn to change fire policies to mitigate (not prevent) such tragedies in the future. Wildfires are a natural part…
-
Can Prescribe Burning Reduce Smoke In Summer?
A recent Bend Bulletin Editorial repeated the numerous misconceptions about prescribed burning. The commentary suggested that more prescribed burning would reduce smoke in Bend during the summer months. While I agree that less smoke would be a great outcome, prescribed burning will not accomplish that for several reasons. First, much of the smoke we experience…
-
It’s The Wind Stupid
During the 1992 Presidential Election cycle, political advisor James Carville devised a brief and successful mantra that helped Bill Clinton win the election: “It’s the economy, stupid.” A similar mantra could characterize all large wildfires in the United States: “It’s the wind, stupid.” Although numerous elements contribute to fire spread, including slope, topography, fuel type,…
-
The Good Fire-Bad Fire Myth
I continuously see articles in the media about “good fire, ” defined as frequent and low–severity. In other words, such fire seldom kills mature trees. These fires, we are told, mimic “historical” conditions, creating “healthy” ecosystems by clearing away fuels without killing mature trees. A “good fire” by happy coincidence reduces high-severity blazes or so…
-
Crown Jewels A Video That Promotes Forest Degradation
I just finished watching the film Crown Jewels. Many conservation groups are promoting the movie, but few are willing to critique some of the flawed premises in the video. It is admirable that the filmmakers want people to appreciate old-growth forests. But their message is confusing. On the one hand, they promote the idea that…