The other end of the tar sands monstrosity. The Keystone Pipeline
Canadian tar sands are not just about turning Alberta’s boreal forest into a wasteland.
Transport of the product has many dangers, ill-effects.
____________
They haul their giant equipment around the world disrupting the roadside environment to dig tar sands in Alberta, turning hundreds of square miles into lifeless pits. Ah, but they produce oil! They call it Syncrude. Every barrel undermines efforts to develop clean energy because Syncrude’s system is probably the dirtiest energy system on the planet.
They transport the artificial oil from Alberta to refineries in Illinois and Oklahoma using the Keystone Pipeline. Of course, it won’t surprise anyone to hear it leaks. The U.S. Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration shut the pipeline down this month because of leaks in North Dakota and Kansas. Despite continuing problems with the existing pipeline, there is a bigger and badder sibling on the the way — Keystone XL — unless Secretary of State Hillary Clinton blocks it. Worried Republicans want to have the Tar Sands Pipeline Fast-Tracked. Manitoba is helping Canada block the efforts of its oil province, Alberta, by setting up a two million acre Heart of the Boreal Forest” reserve.
The pipeline’s direct danger is to U.S. agriculture, prairie wetlands, and the drinking water of six states. It crosses the huge Ogallala aquifer and poses a special danger to the Nebraska sandhills.
Politically the Koch Brothers are thought to have a big stake in the Keystone XL, but they have stonewalled congressional inquiry efforts through their proxies. Reports after the 2010 elections indicate these fabulously rich rightwingers now “own” the critical House Energy and Commerce Committee. Koch Bros. Accused of Stonewalling Congress on Their Keystone XL Pipeline Interest. Reuters.
More generally the development of the tar sands shows the pernicious effects of developing more and more marginal sources of fossil fuels. Each barrel of “oil” produced costs more energy to make — net energy is less than older, now depleted sources. Negative externalities (spillover effects on innocent “bystanders”) are greater than older sources. The spillover effects generate political opposition from those harmed. The industry that wants to continue passing on the costs of its production to the environment and bystanders grows more aggressive and hostile in order to force its way.
Those folks in Idaho and Montana struggling to save their roads, rivers, and communities from the tar sands giant are just part of many people struggling against the worst kind of corporate-right wing-purchased government policy.
Con. Oil Sands: The Costs of Alberta’s “Black Gold”. Worldwatch Institute
Pro. Syncrude Oil Sand Mine, Alberta, Canada. Mining Technology.com

Ralph Maughan
Dr. Ralph Maughan is professor emeritus of political science at Idaho State University. He has been a Western Watersheds Project Board Member off and on for many years, and also its President. For many years he produced Ralph Maughan's Wolf Report. He was a founder of the Greater Yellowstone Coalition. He and Jackie Johnson Maughan wrote three editions of "Hiking Idaho." He also wrote "Beyond the Tetons" and "Backpacking Wyoming's Teton and Washakie Wilderness." He created and is the administrator of The Wildlife News.
One Response to The other end of the tar sands monstrosity. The Keystone Pipeline
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Recent Posts
- “Stick to the Facts”–How Green Groups Fail to Protect the Gallatin Range May 23, 2022
- Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court May 19, 2022
- BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review May 17, 2022
- Conservation Groups Threaten To Sue On East Paradise Grazing Decision May 12, 2022
- Gratitude for National Parks May 11, 2022
Recent Comments
- Maggie Frazier on “Stick to the Facts”–How Green Groups Fail to Protect the Gallatin Range
- Maggie Frazier on “Stick to the Facts”–How Green Groups Fail to Protect the Gallatin Range
- Ida Lupine on “Stick to the Facts”–How Green Groups Fail to Protect the Gallatin Range
- Ida Lupine on “Stick to the Facts”–How Green Groups Fail to Protect the Gallatin Range
- Nancy Ostlie on “Stick to the Facts”–How Green Groups Fail to Protect the Gallatin Range
- Jannett Heckert on Conservation Groups Threaten To Sue On East Paradise Grazing Decision
- Rich on Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court
- Jannett Heckert on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- rastadoggie on Gratitude for National Parks
- rastadoggie on Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court
- Megan on Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court
- Ida Lupine on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Ida Lupine on Bi State Sage Grouse Reinstated As Proposed Threatened By Court
- Robert Raven on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
- Martha S. Bibb on BLM Fails To Protect Public Patrimony Through Renewal of Grazing Privileges Without Environmental Review
Thanks for posting on this subject, Ralph, and for recognizing the hard work done by the rural people of north Idaho.
http://www.fightinggoliath.org/